1
Parkway
Parkway Express
1490 Brentwood RdBay Shore, NY
$4.09
P: $4.89 D: $5.69
per gal Gas Prices in Bay Shore
23 stations in Suffolk County — updated Sep 14, 8:05 AM
Find the cheapest gas prices in Bay Shore, Suffolk County today. We track 23 gas stations across Bay Shore and update prices daily using GasBuddy data. Bay Shore is located in Suffolk County on Long Island, near Sunrise Highway, Southern State Parkway, Sagtikos Parkway. Compare regular, mid-grade, premium, and diesel prices below to save on your daily commute. The average regular gas price in Bay Shore is currently $4.33/gallon. The cheapest gas is $4.09 at Parkway Express.
$4.09 Cheapest
$4.33 Average
23 Stations
2
CITGO
Sunoco
1310 5th AveBay Shore, NY
$4.09
3
BP
BP
1490 5th AveBay Shore, NY
$4.13
P: $4.93 D: $5.79
per gal 4
76
76
989 Sunrise HwyBay Shore, NY
$4.27
M: $4.59 P: $4.99 D: $5.79
per gal 5
Shell
Shell
1508 5th AveBay Shore, NY
$4.28
M: $4.99 P: $5.19 D: $5.99
per gal 6
USA
USA
95 Moffitt BlvdBay Shore, NY
$4.33
M: $4.89 P: $5.11 D: $6.11
per gal 7
Shell
Shell
515 E Main StBay Shore, NY
$4.35
M: $4.89 P: $5.35
per gal 8
Speedway
Speedway
327 E Main StBay Shore, NY
$4.35
M: $4.89 P: $5.35 D: $6.19
per gal 9
Valero
Valero
1692 Union BlvdBay Shore, NY
$4.35
M: $5.11 P: $5.17
per gal 10
7-Eleven
7-Eleven
2320 Union BlvdBay Shore, NY
$4.35
M: $4.95 P: $5.35 D: $6.19
per gal 11
Sinclair
Sinclair
645 Main StBay Shore, NY
$4.37
M: $4.77 P: $5.07
per gal 12
BP
BP
1320 5TH AVEBay Shore, NY
$4.39
13
BP
BP
195 Pine Aire DrBay Shore, NY
$4.39
M: $4.69 P: $5.09
per gal 14
Exxon
Exxon
172 Howells RdBay Shore, NY
$4.39
M: $4.89 P: $5.29
per gal 15
Mobil
Mobil
211 5th AveBay Shore, NY
$4.39
M: $4.79 P: $5.19
per gal 16
Mobil
Mobil
221 W Main StBay Shore, NY
$4.39
M: $5.09 P: $5.29 D: $6.29
per gal 17
Mobil
Mobil
1050 Udall RdBay Shore, NY
$4.39
M: $4.69 P: $5.19 D: $6.29
per gal 18
Mobil
Mobil
236 Bay Shore RdBay Shore, NY
$4.39
M: $4.59 P: $4.99 D: $6.39
per gal 19
Shell
Shell
168 Howells RdBay Shore, NY
$4.39
M: $5.09 P: $5.24 D: $5.98
per gal 20
Valero
Valero
2307 Union BlvdBay Shore, NY
$4.39
M: $4.83 P: $5.09 D: $6.05
per gal 21
Exxon
Exxon
570 Sunrise HwyWest Islip, NY
$4.43
M: $4.79 P: $5.29 D: $5.89
per gal 22
Shell
Shell
1701 Union BlvdBay Shore, NY
$4.45
M: $5.27 P: $5.49
per gal 23
OK
OK Petroleum
1862 5th AveBrentwood, NY
—
D: $6.05
per gal More Cheap Gas Near Bay Shore
Worth the short drive if the price gap covers it — ranked by price, distance-adjusted.
Bay Shore Gas Price Context
The Suffolk County average for regular is currently $4.31/gal versus $4.31 across all of Long Island. If your commute runs along Sunrise Highway or Southern State Parkway, check prices at both ends of the trip — the spread between the cheapest and priciest Long Island stations is regularly more than a dollar per gallon, and warehouse clubs (Costco, BJ's) reliably sit at the bottom of the table. Hit a pothole on the way? The Bay Shore tire shop directory shows live open-now status, and our roadside safety analysis covers what to do if it happens on a parkway.
FAQ — Gas in Bay Shore
Where is the cheapest gas near Bay Shore right now?
The cheapest gas in Bay Shore is $4.09/gal regular at Parkway Express. Prices update throughout the day — the full ranked list is above.
Is gas in Suffolk County cheaper than the Long Island average?
Suffolk County currently averages $4.31/gal regular versus $4.31 island-wide — slightly cheaper than the Long Island average. Individual stations matter more than averages: the island-wide spread is often more than a dollar per gallon.
How often are Bay Shore gas prices updated?
Prices are pulled from crowd-reported and posted-price feeds and republished throughout the day — this page was last rebuilt Sep 14, 8:05 AM. Each station card shows regular, midgrade, premium, and diesel where reported.